An interesting spicy baked fish recipe with lemon, Dijon mustard and garlic you can easily make in a sheet pan. Baking fish fillet is one of the most delicious and healthiest ways to cook fish. Stop cooking lemon-herb fish with saturated fat like butter and cream!
Trying to cook fish for the first time? Find out how to make spicy baked fish in the oven with this simple low-calorie fish recipe. In this recipe, we brush the fish steaks (or fillets) with the lemon-mustard-garlic sauce and bake them. You’ll be wondering why you require that much butter or cream to bake fish when you can make healthy lemon mustard baked fish that doesn’t require either. Let me show you the trick to make it juicy and flavorful.
Spicy, tangy and tender, the baked lemon-herb fish can be eaten with sides like no-mayo coleslaw for a low carb and low-calorie seafood dinner. Or save time and effort by making it a sheet pan dinner by roasting thinly sliced vegetables alongside the fish. (See instructions in the recipe card at the end of the post.) It’s also the perfect baked fish recipe to make in big batches for a hungry crowd.
If you’re getting started with fish and love spicy fish recipes, another easy fish recipe to try is simple fish cakes without potato.
If you like spicy baked fish with a crunchy topping, try making the baked cod with Panko crumbs which is an adaptation of this recipe and equally delicious!
If you are a person who wants to spend less time in the kitchen but still show off some amazing dishes that look like they’re worth a million dollars, then we are in this together. This spicy baked fish with lemon and mustard can look like you spent hours in the kitchen when in reality you just need 10 minutes for preparing, then leave the rest to your oven.
What fish is good for baking?
I used mackerel steaks (kingfish) here, but this recipe is versatile. Steaks or fillets of other oily fish like tuna or white fish like cod, sea bass, tilapia or halibut work great! That being said, firm white fish steaks like mackerel, bass or cod can hold their shape better and can be marinated for up to an hour. This helps the fish absorb more of the flavor, making it juicy.
If you’re worried about bones in fish steaks, you can absolutely use fillets. Increase the baking time by 5 minutes for every additional inch of thickness of the fillet. (Go by the thickest part.) I like steaks because they have uniform thickness and cook evenly. I don’t mind picking out the bones. That’s the compromise you make!
My latest videos
Cooking at a low temperature – the best way to bake fish
- Baking at temperatures as low as 100°C/ 212°F with lemon, mustard and garlic makes the fish juicy and tender. (That’s the reason oven-baked salmon kabobs also turn out so delicious!)
- The simple seasoning and the lemon mustard glaze give a ton of flavor to the fish, making you literally drool. You don’t have to bake fish that is swimming in high-calorie creamy sauce or butter to make it taste good.
- Slow cooking preserves the omega-3 fats and other nutrients of the fish since you’re not subjecting it to high temperatures.
- Initial seasoning for fish: Chili powder, oil and salt.
- Lemon-herb seasoning: Dijon mustard, garlic, cumin, chili flakes, cilantro, lemon juice and zest.
How to make spicy baked fish- step by step
(You can find the exact measurements and instructions in the recipe card at the end of this page.)
Season the fish with chili powder, salt and vegetable oil. Let it marinate for 10 to 15 minutes. Meanwhile, prepare the lemon mustard sauce.
How to make lemon mustard sauce for fish
Blend together Dijon mustard, garlic, chili flakes, ground cumin, salt, lemon peel, lemon juice into a smooth paste. A small spice blender is required here since the quantity of ingredients is quite less. If you don’t have one, it makes sense to multiply the recipe, make a big batch and freeze the leftovers. Once you make this baked fish, you may get addicted to it and the frozen stuff will be used up in no time!
Another option is to mince garlic and zest the lemon and mix with the other ingredients. This way you can whip up the sauce and don’t require a blender.
Slather the lemon mustard marinade on the fish steaks (or fillets) and sprinkle some chopped cilantro on top.
How to bake fish
Place the fish steaks on a sheet pan or baking dish in a single layer. Bake for 20 to 25 minutes. Check for doneness in the middle part of the steak. It should be opaque and flake apart easily. Let the baked fish stand for 5 minutes. Devour!
Spicy fish, lemon, Dijon mustard and garlic – the combo is always a win-win situation!
- The fish can be marinated longer, upto an hour.
- When you blend the lemon mustard paste, add a few stalks of cilantro for added flavor.
- Be patient. Bake the fish at 100°C/ 212°F for 20 to 25 minutes (for 1-inch thick fillet or steak) for the best results. Baking at higher temperatures tends to dry out the fish.
Spicy Baked Fish pairs well with
- No-mayo coleslaw
- Microwave-fried okra
- Easy French beans with mustard
- Beet orange salad with coconut
- Mango pomegranate fruit salad
Do mustard and fish go together?
Mustard complements the flavor of a simple fish fillet very well. When you bake fish with mustard, it not only makes it more spicy, tangy and delicious, it also gives a creamy glaze to the fish.
Why is my fish chewy?
Cooking fish for too long draws out moisture and tends to dry out the fish, especially when you bake uncovered in the oven. So it is essential to follow the time specified in the recipe instructions for the fish to turn out soft and juicy.
What is the healthiest way to cook fish?
Baking is one of the healthiest ways to cook fish. In this recipe, we’re slow-baking fish at a low temperature. This ensures that the nutrients and fatty acids in the fish are preserved. You also get fish fillets that are great in texture and flavor.
Can fish be pink in the middle?
White fish has to be cooked until it is opaque throughout and flakes easily. Always check in the middle or the thickest part of the fish for doneness. Fish being pink in the middle means it is undercooked. (Salmon is an exception- white patches on the surface of cooked salmon mean it is overcooked.)
More seafood recipes you will love
★★★★★Did you try this recipe? Please give a star rating in the comments below.★★★★★
HUNGRY FOR MORE? Join over 1000 home cooks like you who subscribe to my weekly newsletter to get all the latest recipes right in your inbox.
Thank you and happy cooking!